Skip to Content

15 Best Starter Homes You’ll Find in Ohio

15 Best Starter Homes You’ll Find in Ohio

Looking for an affordable first home in the Buckeye State? Ohio offers some amazing starter home options that won’t break the bank.

From cozy Toledo bungalows to charming Columbus condos, these properties provide the perfect launching pad for new homeowners while keeping monthly payments manageable.

1. Toledo Gem on Toronto Avenue

Toledo Gem on Toronto Avenue
© Zillow

Nestled in a friendly neighborhood, this 2-bedroom home on Toronto Avenue offers surprising space with 1,301 square feet and 1.5 bathrooms. At just $65,000, it’s a steal for first-time buyers!

Original hardwood floors add character throughout this 1950s property. The half-finished basement provides extra storage or potential for a home office setup.

2. Spacious Everett Street Bargain

Spacious Everett Street Bargain
© Zillow

Imagine owning a 3-bedroom home with 1,440 square feet for under $70K! This Everett Street property delivers incredible value with its generous room sizes and solid construction.

Walk through the welcoming front porch into a bright living area perfect for gatherings. The large backyard provides ample space for gardening, pets, or outdoor entertaining.

3. East Pearl Street Charmer

East Pearl Street Charmer
© Zillow

Budget-conscious buyers will adore this 3-bedroom pearl on E Pearl Street. With pricing well under $100K, it represents true affordability in today’s challenging market.

Sunlight streams through large windows, creating a cheerful atmosphere throughout. The remodeled kitchen features newer appliances and convenient layout for easy meal preparation.

4. Middletown Boulevard Beauty

Middletown Boulevard Beauty
© Realty Ohio Real Estate

Priced at just $85,000, this Carmody Boulevard residence offers 2 bedrooms in a neighborhood known for its community spirit. First-time homeowners will appreciate the move-in ready condition.

Recently updated bathroom fixtures add modern touches to this established home. The attached garage provides secure parking and additional storage for outdoor equipment and seasonal items.

5. Auburn Street Cozy Cottage

Auburn Street Cozy Cottage
© Redfin

Single professionals or empty nesters will fall in love with this $60,000 one-bedroom gem on Auburn Street. Compact yet perfectly formed, this property maximizes every square foot.

A picturesque bay window creates a charming reading nook in the living room. Behind the house, a fenced yard offers privacy for outdoor relaxation or container gardening.

6. Rufus Street Ranch Home

Rufus Street Ranch Home
© Zillow

Just shy of $95K, this Rufus Street ranch-style property delivers two comfortable bedrooms and easy single-level living. No stairs means accessibility for all ages and abilities!

Vaulted ceilings create an airy, spacious feeling throughout the main living areas. The covered back patio extends your living space outdoors, perfect for morning coffee or evening relaxation.

7. Clarendon Avenue Family Haven

Clarendon Avenue Family Haven
© Zillow

Growing families will appreciate this three-bedroom Clarendon Avenue treasure priced at only $75,000. Room to grow without stretching your budget makes this an ideal starter property.

Kids will love the spacious backyard with room for play equipment and games. The eat-in kitchen features ample counter space and cabinetry, making meal preparation a family affair.

8. 11th Avenue Bungalow Bargain

11th Avenue Bungalow Bargain
© Zillow

Vintage charm abounds in this $79,900 bungalow on 11th Avenue. With two bedrooms and classic architectural details, it’s perfect for buyers who appreciate character homes.

Arched doorways and built-in shelving showcase the craftsmanship of yesteryear. The deep front porch offers a welcoming spot to enjoy neighborhood views and connect with passing neighbors.

9. Yankee Road Corner Lot

Yankee Road Corner Lot
© Zillow

Right at the $100K mark, this Yankee Road property sits on a desirable corner lot with excellent curb appeal. Two bedrooms provide comfortable living space for singles or couples.

Extra windows on both street-facing sides flood the home with natural light. The spacious side yard offers flexibility for gardening, outdoor dining, or future expansion possibilities.

10. Zanesville Mound Street Treasure

Zanesville Mound Street Treasure
© Trulia

Moving up slightly in price, this $109,000 Mound Street home offers two bedrooms plus two full bathrooms – a rare find in this price range! Convenience meets comfort in this well-maintained property.

Equipped with modern amenities while preserving its original character. Having two bathrooms eliminates morning rush congestion, making daily routines much more pleasant for couples or roommates.

11. Brighton Boulevard Beauty

Brighton Boulevard Beauty
© WhiteStone Real Estate

Worth every penny of its $124,900 price tag, this Brighton Boulevard property boasts three bedrooms in a desirable Zanesville location. Schools, shopping, and parks are all within easy reach.

Recent kitchen updates include stainless steel appliances and trendy backsplash. The partially finished basement provides bonus living space that could serve as a home gym, office, or entertainment zone.

12. Rehl Road Country Setting

Rehl Road Country Setting
© Zillow

Escape the hustle and bustle with this $124,900 three-bedroom home on Rehl Road. Situated on a larger lot, it offers a taste of country living while maintaining city conveniences.

Mature trees provide welcome shade and privacy around the property. The oversized detached garage offers space for vehicles plus workshop area for hobbies or home projects.

13. Spangler Drive Rancher

Spangler Drive Rancher
© Zillow

Single-level living shines in this $109,900 Spangler Drive ranch home. With two bedrooms and an open concept design, it’s perfect for those seeking modern convenience without stairs.

Updated flooring throughout creates a cohesive, contemporary feel. The attached garage connects directly to the kitchen, making grocery unloading a breeze even during Ohio’s unpredictable weather.

14. Westerville Road Condo Steal

Westerville Road Condo Steal
© Zillow

Jaw-dropping affordability at just $32,000! This Westerville Road condo offers two bedrooms and maintenance-free living – ideal for busy professionals or those looking to downsize.

Community amenities might include shared green spaces and parking. Monthly association fees cover exterior maintenance and some utilities, removing the stress of unexpected repair costs.

15. Stelzer Road Urban Opportunity

Stelzer Road Urban Opportunity
© Redfin

Rounding out our list at an incredible $34,000, this Stelzer Road property offers three bedrooms in Columbus – Ohio’s thriving capital city! Location and price make this an unbeatable investment opportunity.

Close proximity to major employers and transportation corridors adds convenience. The solid structure provides an excellent canvas for buyers looking to add their personal touches through cosmetic updates.