Tucked along the Montauk coastline, The Stone House isn’t just another beach estate, it’s a piece of history with soul. Originally built in 1912 and thoughtfully reimagined in 1991 by Tony Ingrao, this home blends old-world craftsmanship with modern luxury.
With just two bedrooms and two and a half baths, it’s intimate but unforgettable, featuring hand-carved wood, custom copper windows, and jaw-dropping views of the Montauk Lighthouse and Block Island.
I was especially taken by the saltwater pool and the artist’s studio, pure inspiration. At $18 million, it’s not just a home. It’s a legacy on 3.2 oceanfront acres.
1. Coastal Estate Grounds
This peaceful property features two distinctive homes tucked among tall trees, thick shrubbery, and carefully trimmed hedges.
The main stone house stands proudly near the water’s edge, its steep gabled roof and tall chimneys adding to its timeless presence. Just below, a smaller wooden cottage blends effortlessly into the greenery, its simple lines and earthy tones echoing the natural landscape.
Winding paths and discreet driveways weave through the land, balancing elegance with the wild beauty of the ocean beyond.
2. Coastal Estate Aerial
Surrounded by thick greenery that stretches inland, the estate feels private and deeply connected to the land. Ivy climbs its gabled rooflines and stone chimneys, adding age and character to the elegant structure.
A neatly kept lawn curves around the home, bordered by hedges. Far in the distance, a lone white lighthouse marks the edge of the peninsula, completing this serene and unforgettable seaside view.
3. Coastal Cliffside Estate
Perched high on a windswept cliff, this historic stone mansion basks in the golden light of late afternoon. Its steep roofs, stately chimneys, and dormer windows nod to classic American design while framing endless ocean views.
A set of weathered stairs winds down the cliffside to the rocky shore below, where waves roll in gently. Wild grasses and hardy shrubs surround the home, softening the rugged terrain.
With the calm sea and open sky beyond, the whole scene feels timeless and deeply peaceful.
4. Oceanfront Balcony View
There’s something calming about standing on this wooden balcony, where classic balusters frame a wide-open view of the ocean.
Two rustic lounge chairs sit side by side, angled just right to catch the sea breeze and endless horizon. Below, a stretch of green grass meets the edge of the deep blue water, blending land and sea in the most peaceful way.
The worn wood underfoot adds a sense of history, making this the perfect spot for slow mornings or quiet sunsets.
5. Guest Cottage And Pool
Tucked into a lush, tree-filled backyard, this charming guest cottage feels like something out of a storybook. Its steep roof and weathered wood shingles give it timeless character, while a covered entry and cheerful windows add to the warm welcome.
A stone patio wraps around the cottage, offering comfy lounge chairs and a cozy table for poolside chats.
The pool curves gently into the landscape, its flagstone edges and subtle fencing blending seamlessly with the greenery and creating a peaceful, hidden escape.
6. Rustic Kitchen Interior
Step into a kitchen where rustic charm meets timeless elegance. Heavy wooden ceiling beams draw your eyes up, while a stunning stone wall sets the mood with its natural texture.
In the center, a large weathered wood table anchors the space atop classic stone floors. Deep teal cabinets with a vintage, distressed finish bring rich color.
Sleek stainless steel appliances add a modern edge, and a black wrought-iron chandelier glows warmly overhead. Arched wooden doors open wide, welcoming you into this cozy, cottage-inspired retreat.
7. Rustic Dining Room
This dining room feels like a step back in time, where every detail invites you to linger a little longer. Heavy wooden beams stretch overhead, echoing the deep tones of the long dining table and its cushioned, striped chairs.
The stone floor is softened by a vibrant oriental rug, while soft green walls with hand-painted botanicals give the space a peaceful, timeless feel.
Light filters through the windows and a weathered arched door, while iron chandeliers and a grand carved cabinet add to the room’s rich, old-world character.
8. Rustic Attic Bedroom
Tucked beneath a pitched attic roof, this bedroom wraps you in the warmth of weathered wood and timeworn beams that tell a story all their own.
A stately four-poster bed with a tall, upholstered headboard takes center stage, its charm amplified by a floral chest resting at its foot.
Natural light slips in through small windows on either side, softly brightening the space. Patterned rugs break up the wood floor, while a vintage desk and lamp complete the room’s rustic, handcrafted appeal.
9. Rustic Living Room
This cozy living room blends rustic charm with refined details. Weathered wood walls and angled ceilings give it a cabin-like warmth, while the grand stone fireplace adds a touch of historic elegance.
Sunlight pours in through multiple windows, brightening the layered rugs and patterned textiles throughout the space.
A mix of vintage and eclectic furniture surrounds a carved wooden coffee table, creating an inviting spot to relax. Decorative sconces, a ceiling fan, and cozy nooks complete this uniquely atmospheric retreat.
10. Hallway
This hallway exudes old-world charm with its rugged stone walls, exposed wooden beams, and weathered textures throughout.
Natural light filters through a large window, illuminating a ledge adorned with playful ceramic ducks and terracotta pots. A faded runner leads toward a cozy dining space framed by rustic wood and antique furnishings.
A vintage clock and hand-painted cabinet add layers of character, making the space feel warm, lived-in, and lovingly preserved. Every detail whispers of history, craftsmanship, and countryside tranquility.
11. Patio Entrance With Ocean View
Weathered wooden doors with an arched top open to reveal a view that feels straight out of a dream. Set between rugged stone walls, the entrance leads to a timeworn stone patio, where a sturdy wooden table and chairs rest beneath the sun.
The furniture is simple and aged just enough to feel perfectly at home here. Beyond the patio, vibrant green grass meets a rustic fence at the cliff’s edge, with nothing but endless ocean and clear blue sky beyond.